How It Works

We want to give you the most money possible for your signed jewelry, diamonds or gemstones while still being fair to us, and to do so, we go through the following process to gain as much pertinent information as possible. Don’t worry, if things do not work out, we send your items back to you free of charge.
  • Step 1

    Complete the online offer request form below.
  • Step 2

    If we are interested in purchasing, you’ll receive an initial offer from us via email or phone.
  • Step 3

    Ship us your items via FedEx or make an appointment to meet with us in person.
  • Step 4

    Once we receive your item, we’ll contact you via email or phone with an official offer.
  • Step 5

    You decide what to do! Your check or jewelry will be shipped overnight within 24 business hours.
Get Your Offer

What We Buy

Designers We Pay Premium For:

  • Boucheron
  • Buccellati
  • Bulgari
  • Cartier
  • David Webb
  • Harry Winston
  • Hermès
  • Tiffany & Co.
  • Van Cleef & Arpels
  • Verdura
  • and more

Periods We Like to Buy:

  • Georgian
  • Victorian
  • Renaissance Revival
  • Art Nouveau
  • Belle Epoque
  • Edwardian
  • Art Deco
  • Retro
  • Vintage
  • Modern
  • and more

Diamonds & Gemstones We Pay Premium For:

  • GIA Certified Diamonds
  • Natural Color Diamonds
  • Colombian Emeralds
  • Oil-free Emeralds
  • Kashmir Sapphires
  • Burmese Rubies & Sapphires
  • Alexandrites & Demantoids
  • Cat's Eyes & Stars
  • Paraibas & Padparadscha
  • Unheated & Untreated Gemstones
  • and more

Jewelry & Other Items We Buy:

  • Earrings
  • Necklaces
  • Rings
  • Bracelets
  • Brooches & Pins
  • Watches
  • Jewelry Suites
  • Collectibles & Objets d’ Art
  • Gold & Other Precious Metals
  • Entire Estates
  • and more

Factors that Determine the Value of
Your Jewelry

  • Beauty
    Rarity
    Designer/Brand
  • Collectability/Demand
    Comparable Market Prices
    Provenance
  • Condition
    Intrinsic Value
    Historic Period

Why Sell to J.S. Fearnley?

J.S. Fearnley offers a free consultation to help you sell your jewelry, gemstones or diamonds even if it means referring you somewhere else. We will clearly outline your options allowing you to make an educated decision. There is no better place to sell your special jewelry, gemstones or diamonds than J.S. Fearnley. Unlike most buyers limited to their area, our exclusive and extensive clientele list spans the globe including multiple major cities and countries, which we regularly travel to every year. This provides J.S. Fearnley with an unparalleled market reach and knowledge of the true market value allowing us to offer you the most for your special piece of jewelry. J.S. Fearnley will know where to market your jewelry and pay you top dollar. We buy with immediate payment, but consignment or brokering is an option, as well. To make an appointment please fill out the form below. If you would like more details, there is some valuable advice on our FAQs page here. Get Your Offer